Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Lunch Box
30 Pieces Custom Tray
30 Pieces Simple Tray
18 Pieces Custom Tray
About
Toasty-Subs
Welcome to the delightful world of Toasty-Subs, where satisfying cravings with scrumptious sandwiches takes center stage. Located at 2020 S MacArthur Blvd, Springfield, IL, this cozy eatery is not just a place to grab a bite; it's a sanctuary for sandwich enthusiasts. With a commitment to quality ingredients and mouth-watering combinations, Toasty-Subs is redefining fast dining.
Toasty-Subs specializes in hearty sandwiches, offering a menu that features a variety of choices. Classics like the Arnold's Reuben—a delectable mix of corned beef, provolone, and sauerkraut pressed between rye bread—stand out for their robustness. For a more adventurous palate, the Bombay sandwich, layered with Bombay-style potatoes and mozzarella on Texas Toast, will transport you straight to the streets of India.
Highlights of the Offerings:
- Arnold's Reuben: A traditional favorite that’s brimming with flavor.
- BLT : Perfectly toasted on sweet bread, this classic combo of bacon, lettuce, and tomatoes is a must-try.
- Sandwich Sides: Dive into their selection of sides like cheesy breadsticks or a fresh house salad, complementing your meal beautifully.
Feedback from patrons speaks volumes about their experiences. Many rave about the consistently excellent food, while others highlight the speedy service ideal for takeout. One enthusiastic customer, Peter W., remarked that Toasty-Subs fills an essential void in Springfield's food scene, while Alyssa M. describes it as an "underrated gem." Another reviewer, Tobi O., expressed his admiration for both the "too good" sandwiches and the top-notch customer service.
The ambience might be small, but the flavors are bold and the options, diverse. From savory subs to fresh baked goodies like chocolate chip cookies and cheesecake brownies, there's something to satisfy every sweet tooth. And for those looking to cater, the customizable lunch boxes and trays make it a perfect choice for gatherings.
In the heart of Springfield, Toasty-Subs proves that simple, quality food can create joyful moments around the dining table. Whether you're stopping by for a quick lunch or ordering delivery, each visit promises delicious discoveries that keep foodies coming back for more.
For inquiries or to place your order, you can reach them at (217) 679-5664. Don’t miss out on supporting this local treasure—after all, great sandwiches deserve a place in your heart!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Consistently good food. I'm sorry to see them go, leaves a hole in Springfield food options. ”
“ I highly recommend this place! Underrated for sure, I havnt had anything I didn't enjoy. ”
“ Good sandwiches. Best for takeaway as the restaurant is very small. The service is pretty quick. ”
“ The subs and ambience are too good. It's a must visit! Customer service is also top notch and they are very helpful. ”
“ Support local. Support national food/drinks days. You get me. We can be best friends! On national Eat a hoagie day where should I go, I picked Toasty-Subs. I ordered the Toasty-Subs Special Club with ham, turkey, bacon, and cheddar cheese, served toasted on sweet bread and added lettuce and tomatoes. You get the choice of a side and they have a ton of options from chips to a banana to a brownie. I went for the Parmesan ranch chips as I'd never seen this brand or flavor before. Great pick as the chips were really good. After I ordered I had no idea what the price was going to be as prices are not listed on the website or on the banner menu above the register. It was $12.99 before tax and tip. After snapping a picture of the whole sandwich for my Yelpers, I cut it into fourths. The bread was so fresh and delicious as were the rest of the ingredients. I would have loved double cheese as it got lost in the sea of meats after it was melted onto the ham. The huge sandwich ended up being three separate meals for me, so totally worth the price point. They also threw in a free sample of their Parmesan pesto pasta salad. Thank you kind sir, that was yummy too! ”
“ Hidden Gem right off the highway! We were passing through looking for a quick healthy meal and ran across this amazing hot sun Sandwich spot. The place was clean and the food was really tasty and fresh! The owner was very nice and welcoming. Definitely happy we found this spot. Do yourself a favor and grab a sub and support a local small business! ”
“ I ordered some sandwiches via Uber eats, and admittedly I had low expectations. I mean, it's paninis, how good could they be? Little did I know, these subs were exactly what I needed. The order arrived super fast (not quite as freaky fast as another sub place known for quick delivery, but within 20 minutes of ordering). The subs were wrapped in paper and our sandwiches were delivered safely and intact. But we soon demolished them! I had the Italian stallion and it was delish! Perfect combination of flavors. I basically inhaled the entire thing within minutes. And the portion was quite generous and I was full for hours. We had also ordered the pickles and I tried one and it just wasn't really my thing- a little too soggy for my taste. In all, I'd definitely recommend Toasty Subs and will be keeping them in mind! ”
“ Incredible subs, simply outstanding. I haven't had such a delicious Bombay Sandwich since I was in Mumbai a few years ago, and the fact that they sell one here in a place like Springfield is incredible. Their Italian Stallion is also one of the best sandwiches I have ever tasted - the ratio of meat to bread to sauce to peppers is perfect, and you can absolutely taste the high quality of the meat. I'm going back a 3rd day in a row now, can't wait to try another sandwich and see them knock it out of the park yet again. ”
“ We tried the Reuben and the Cubano and both were excellent. Several vegetarian options that sounded really good (will be back to try the buffalo cauliflower). This place will be good addition to South MacArthur! ”
